Guide 4 of 5
Who was at fault, and how it is shown
The short answer
More than one driver can share the blame for a crash. What your own share does to your claim is set by state law, and the rule for each state is in the key rules on this page.
The shares themselves come down to evidence, so the useful work in the first weeks is collecting it before it is gone.
What shows who caused it
- Photos of where the cars ended up, the damage to each one, the road surface, the signs and the signals.
- The name and number of everyone who saw it. Someone who knows neither driver is worth finding.
- Video. A dash camera, a doorbell or a nearby shop may have recorded it. Ask quickly, because many systems record over themselves.
- Your own account, written down while it is fresh: where you were coming from, your lane, the light, and what you saw the other car do.
- What the other driver said at the scene, as close to the exact words as you can remember.
The police report
If an officer came, the report records what the officer saw and was told, and sometimes the officer’s view of the cause. Insurance companies read it closely.
A report can be wrong. If yours has a mistake, such as the wrong direction of travel or a witness left out, ask the agency how to add a correction or a statement of your own. Drivers have reporting duties of their own as well. Key rule: crash reports
What each driver did at the scene
State law sets out what a driver has to do after a crash. Write down what the other driver did and did not do, and whether the cars were moved before the photos were taken. Key rule: at the scene
When the other insurer says it was your fault
The other driver’s insurance company may tell you that you were partly or mostly to blame. That is the company’s position. It is not a ruling by a court. Ask for it in writing, with the reasons, and show it to a lawyer.
When it is not clear
Some crashes are harder to sort out than others: a lane change, a left turn across traffic, a parking lot, a chain of several cars. If yours is one of them, collect what you can early, and ask for help before you give anyone a detailed account.
Key rules
These are the rules of law this page relies on. Each one is a general statement with exceptions that are not shown, and each links to the statute, regulation or court decision it comes from.
| Topic | California | Washington |
|---|---|---|
| Shared fault | California cuts your damages by your own percentage of responsibility. There is no cutoff, so a person who was mostly at fault can still recover something. Source: Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804; CACI No. 405 | Your share of the fault lowers your damages by that percentage and does not bar the claim. There is one exception. Being under the influence can bar a claimant entirely, if it was a cause of the injury and the claimant’s own fault was more than 50 percent. Source: RCW 4.22.005; RCW 5.40.060 |
| At the scene | A driver in a crash must stop at once, give a name, address and vehicle registration, show a license if asked, and give reasonable assistance to anyone injured, which includes arranging medical care. Source: Cal. Veh. Code §§ 20001 to 20003 | Every driver involved must stop and hand over a name, address, insurance company, policy number and license plate, show a driver’s license, and give reasonable assistance to anyone injured. If the crash damaged only property, the driver must get the vehicles off the road as soon as possible, and doing so has no bearing on who was at fault. Source: RCW 46.52.020 |
| Crash reports | There are two reports, and they are separate. When someone is injured or killed, a driver in the crash must see that a written report reaches the CHP or the city police within 24 hours. Form SR 1 must also go to the DMV within 10 days after any crash that injured or killed someone or did more than $1,000 of damage to the property of any one person. Source: Cal. Veh. Code §§ 16000, 20008 | Where no officer investigates, the driver has four days to file a collision report if the crash injured or killed anyone, or caused $1,000 or more of damage to the property of any one person. Source: RCW 46.52.030; WAC 446-85-010 |
Sources
- California. Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804; CACI No. 405
- California. Cal. Veh. Code §§ 20001 to 20003
- California. Cal. Veh. Code §§ 16000, 20008
- Washington. RCW 4.22.005; RCW 5.40.060
- Washington. RCW 46.52.020
- Washington. RCW 46.52.030; WAC 446-85-010
The rules on this page were last checked against these sources on October 3, 2026. Laws change, so follow the link before you rely on a rule.
Attorney review in progress. Responsible attorney: Emery Brett Ledger. Page last updated November 12, 2026.